I often lose myself in the morbid; the endless wikipedia trail of serial killers, cannibalism, court cases chronicling terrible abuses, war stories and the worst kind of mental disorders. But I'm totally normal. It's just a quirk, right?
A terrible event which I often mindlessly slip into the google search bar, looking to see if there are any new articles, is the abuse and death of Sylvia Likens.
I learned of the Sylvia off-handedly from a teacher in high school, and became obsessed with the story. To summarize Sylvia's experience is to belittle it, I really suggest you read the whole story.
How far gone someone has to be to allow this to happen, and how, either brainwashed or apathetic, the kids involved were not to question it. Several films have been made of the event, the most accurate being 2007's An American Crime.
I can see how this case can be the inspiration of many books; both on law and pshychology, and was represented very well in a film, where make-up and actual elapsing of days while filming benefit the harsh narrative of the final days of Sylvia's life, but I was very interested to learn a play based on the events entitled 'Down There' by Randy Sharp is running in the Village at the Axis Theatre.

The theater offers a summery of the play on their website, and though the names of each character have been changed, the story seems to follow what did happen in that suburban basement in Indiana.
I have yet to see the play and I am not quite sure I want to. Audience reviews call the play confusing and leaving much of the graphic abuse to the audiences imagination. I realize it would be difficult to actually stage and act much of the violence, but I think the voyeur in me (as well as the rest of the audience) would find that aspect disappointing.
Another problem with the play is that tries to answer the baffling question of how such a thing could happen. Why Gertrude was so sadistic, why none of the kids, neighbors or Sylvia's sister did anything, what moral compass allowed kids to drink soda on the street, go down to a basement and torure a peer, and then do it all again the next day. And even more so why Sylvia was so submissive?
These are questions years of analysis, as well as the participants of the horrific events themselves have not been able to answer. And attempting to do so in a 80 minute play seems to turn the event into a race towards a meaning and what it really was, just plainly one of the most terrible crimes in American history. Critics tend to agree.
While writing this blog entry I realized I have no intention of going 'Down There.' Whatever it is that keeps me revisiting Sylvia's story is something I do not wish to have contorted by a play, I think the event enough is more powerful and heartbreaking than any staging and script can convey, and any conclusions a playwright draws will never be the real answer as to why it happened, because there really is none.